February 11, 2015
I was very proud of my natural hair care routine last year especially considering all of the setbacks and shenanigans. First, dealing with a hair snatching earlier last year, adopting new hair styles every month with extensions and even changing my shampoo schedule were all a part of the changes I made. However, recently, I was doing research for some articles and found out that one of my mainstays—my anchors, my core natural hair care regimen item, my detangling conditioner VO5 Moisture Milks—contains a preservative, a formaldehyde releaser called DMDM Hydantoin. According to the Environmental Working Group's Skin Deep Cosmetics Database, this ingredient is a skin irritant and carries a low risk of cancer. Whaaattttt???!!!!
I almost fell out of my chair. I was shocked...but then I thought,... isn't this the way things go? The more you know...the more painful life gets....Ignorance is bliss. Okay, I know I need to stop the melodrama, but it's hard to find a cost effective product which actually works. A couple of years ago, an irritant in a leave in conditioner gave me a fire rash on my neck. So I know that a natural hair care product’s ingredients have to be researched and vetted.
When I e-mailed the company, this is what they told me:
“According to our research, all of our products are safe to the consumer used as directed. We understand your concern and if you are still unsure if it is safe for you to use, you may consult your physician.”
The response was quick, concise and
appreciated, but this didn’t make me want to go to my doctor. It made me want
to do more research. So I did.
With this being a research based natural hair care web site, I appear crazy not researching my products before purchasing them. However, VO5 came along very early in my
journey into natural hair care, even before I started this web
site. And, since it worked really well, I never questioned it (This
is no excuse of course...). Popular
among other naturals, people swore by it. However, I can't have anything near
my skin that has anything to do with formaldehyde. Not good. However, I completely
understand that there is a small amount of it in practically every cosmetic
and beauty aid we use.
Formaldehyde is a “colorless,
strong-smelling gas” found in household building materials such as plywood, fiberboard,
glues and professional keratin hair straightening products. It is “quickly broken down in air within
hours and dissolves in water. It is used
as a powerful disinfectant in medical facilities and funeral homes and is also
used as a preservative. Substances that release formaldehyde are found in
products such as shampoos, some nail polish, conditioners, lotions and
cosmetics (American Cancer Society).
According to the American Cancer Society:
“Exposure to formaldehyde has been shown to cause cancer in laboratory test animals. Exposure to relatively high amounts of formaldehyde in medical and occupational settings has been linked to some types of cancer in humans, but the effect of exposure to small amounts is less clear.”
That phrase “less clear” is what troubles me. Why is there no research about the long term effects of small amounts of these formaldehyde releasers on humans, especially since this type of ingredient is found in so many products? As long as there is no decisive data, people can say that the stuff is harmless because there is no proof that it isn’t. Research would solve that.
I often think to myself if I ate dinner at a friend's house and I was told that there was only a small amount of anthrax in the food being prepared, not enough to kill me but enough to give the buttered biscuits that kick, I know our friendship would be brought into question. I don't know. It's such a dilemma. There are chemical preservatives in practically everything on the store shelf, yet I really want to know what the long term effects of exposure are. My skin is a freeway where toxins—even trace amounts—are absorbed. Each time, I pour a conditioner into my hands and spread it across my hair, the conditioner sits on my hands for my long detangling sessions. While for a single use, the amount of that toxic ingredient may be miniscule, what about its effects over time? Again, this seems to be “less clear.”
Yet in 2010, the FDA released a warning letter about the levels of formaldehyde present in Brazilian Blowout products. They cited labeling violations regarding these products since they lacked sufficient information about the presence of formaldehyde and its effects. After salon treatments, consumers were complaining of chest pain, vomiting, rashes, and respiratory tract problems.
What is so weird about doing natural hair care research is that truly I am often afraid at what I may find. This is not looking good…. Stay tuned for Part II of this article….
Alberto VO5 Moisture Milks Moisturizing Conditioner, Strawberries & Cream (n.d.). In EWG's Skin
Deep Cosmetics Database. Retrieved February 9, 2015 from
FDA, OSHA Act on Brazilian Blowout (2010, October 8). In U.S. Food and Drug Administration.
Formaldehyde (n.d.). In American Cancer Society. Retrieved February 9, 2015, from